Denmark’s burqa ban is not the answer

gulfnews

 

Ah Denmark, what a country. If any society breathes the spirit of liberty, this is it.

It was only a few weeks ago that I was in Copenhagen for some international conference, and as ever I rose early and went for a run. As I passed through some yuppie zone of warehouse conversions and posh restaurants I saw to my amazement that the Danes had also got up early for exercise — and they were diving into the bracing waters of the harbour. I thought to myself: that’s the Danes for you, that’s the spirit of Viking individualism.

Denmark is the only country in Europe, as far as I know, that still devotes a large proportion of its capital city to an anarchist commune, called Christiania, where I remember spending a happy afternoon 25 years ago inhaling the sweet air of freedom. It is the Danes who still hold out against all sorts of EU tyrannies, large and small.

It was the heroic population of Denmark that on that magnificent day in June 1992 voted down the Maastricht treaty — and though that revolt was eventually crushed by the European establishment (as indeed, note, they will try to crush all such revolts), that great nej (no) to Maastricht expressed something about the Danish spirit: a genial, happy cussedness and independence.

It is a spirit you see everywhere on the streets of Copenhagen in the veneration for that supreme embodiment of vehicular autonomy, the bicycle. The Danes don’t cycle with their heads down, grimly, swearing at people who get in their way. They wander and weave, helmetless, down the beautiful boulevards on clapped-out granny bikes, with a culture of cycling in which everyone is treated with courtesy and respect.

Yes, if you wanted to visit a country that seemed on the face of it to embody the principles of John Stuart Mill — that you should be able to do what you want provided you do no harm to others — I would advise you to head for wonderful, wonderful Copenhagen. So I was a bit surprised to see that on August 1 the Danes joined several other European countries — France, Germany, Austria, Belgium — in imposing a ban on the niqab and the burqa.

Dress code

Already, a fine of 1,000 krone — about £120 (Dh572.9) — has been imposed on a 28-year-old woman seen wearing a niqab in a shopping centre in the north-eastern town of Horsholm. A scuffle broke out as someone tried to rip it off her head. There have been demonstrations, on both sides of the argument. What has happened, you may ask, to the Danish spirit of live and let live?

If a constituent came to my MP’s surgery in the UK with her face obscured, I should feel fully entitled — like Jack Straw — to ask her to remove it so that I could talk to her properly. If a female student turned up at school or at a university lecture in that garb: those in authority should be allowed to converse openly with those that they are being asked to instruct.

As for individual businesses or branches of government — they should of course be able to enforce a dress code that enables their employees to interact with customers; and that means human beings must be able to see each other’s faces and read their expressions. It’s how we work in Europe. All that seems to me to be sensible. But such restrictions are not quite the same as telling a freeborn adult woman what she may or may not wear, in a public place, when she is simply minding her own business.

If you go for a total ban, you play into the hands of those who want to politicise and dramatise the so-called clash of civilisations; and you fan the flames of grievance. You risk turning people into martyrs, and you risk a general crackdown on any public symbols of religious affiliation, and you may simply make the problem worse. Like a parent confronted by a rebellious teenager, determined to wear a spike through her tongue or a bolt through her nose, you run the risk that by a heavy-handed attempt to ban something, you simply stiffen resistance.

In Britain, for instance, today there is only a tiny, tiny minority of women who wear these odd bits of headgear. The Danes swim starkers in the heart of Copenhagen. If The Killing is to be believed, their female detectives wear Faroe sweaters on duty, as is their sovereign right. If Danish women really want to cover their faces, then it seems a bit extreme — all the caveats above understood — to stop them under all circumstances. I don’t propose we follow suit. A total ban is not the answer

Source :

gulfnews

Be the first to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


*


seven + seventeen =